11th September 2000
"I have today read in full the document Dominus Jesus which
has given cause for concern and disappointment among, not only the Bishops
of the Church of Ireland, but also Christians of many denominations
throughout the world.
"It is, I believe, clear that parts of the document and indeed the
tone of the document
- are not a reflection of the very positive experiences and
co-operation of Christians and Churches at local level
- appear to run counter to the trend of the significant ecumenical
progress of the past forty years
- and, in its sentiments, is remote from what is actually happening of
note in parishes and communities throughout Ireland.
"In writing for urgent clarification from our brother bishops of
the Catholic Church in Ireland, the Bishops of the Church of Ireland have
underlined the importance they attach to the ecumenical endeavour and the
quest for unity.
"Having devoted my own ministry to ecumenical study and endeavour,
I believe this, rather than becoming a stumbling block, can become a
moment of ecumenical advance. Here is an opportunity, as one Church states
its own position, for bishops, clergy and people of many traditions to
come together to study the document, to share insights and to express
hurts.
"As it is, there is much in this document with which all
Christians will readily agree, while disagreeing resolutely with the
assertion by the document that "the Church" ....
"constituted and organised as a society in the present world,
subsists in the Catholic Church" Face to face, eye to eye ecumenism
framed in a context of common prayer, would surely be much more
challenging and fruitful than the publication of any text."
|